Fall 2011 TV Scorecard: The Best & Worst New Shows

  • Publish Date: December 1, 2011
  • Comments: ↓ 1 user comment

Falling indeed

Image
2011 Homeland Showtime 91
2010 Boardwalk Empire HBO 88
2009 Modern Family ABC 86
2008 Life on Mars ABC 74
2007 Pushing Daisies ABC 86
2006 The Nine ABC 81
2005 Everybody Hates Chris CW 88
Best Reviewed Fall Shows by Year

Sure, there is a crumb of good news: Showtime's riveting terrorism drama Homeland 91 is the best-reviewed new fall series since we initiated our TV coverage in 2005. But that appears to be the one bright spot in a fall season filled mainly with series that can at best be described as serviceable.

The five major broadcast networks debuted 27 new (non-news) primetime shows this fall, up from 22 in 2010. But the average Metascore for this year's freshman class was just 54, down from an average of 57 in both 2010 and 2009. Just 12 of the 27 new fall programs—a mere 44%—received positive reviews from critics, and, even then, those dozen "good" programs averaged a score of 66, with none scoring higher than 70. In other words, reviews were positive, but not overwhelmingly so. Even worse, the networks introduced six new shows over the past few months that were negatively reviewed by critics, compared to just two such programs last fall.

For the second straight year, the fall season's best-reviewed show was on cable rather than broadcast television; indeed, four of the five highest-scoring fall shows aired on cable networks. But Homeland was the only newcomer that managed to score above 80 (the range we use to represent widespread critical acclaim); last fall, three shows exceeded that mark.

Fortunately, the future brings a reason for optimism: many networks seem to have held back their stronger shows for midseason. (Think shows like NBC's Smash, Awake, and The Firm, ABC's The River and Missing, and HBO's Luck). But before we get too far ahead of ourselves, let's go back to fall and see how the broadcast networks rank now that the season has concluded.

Broadcast Network Comparison, Fall 2011 vs. Fall 2010 (New Shows Only)
Network   Fall 2011 New Shows Average
Metascore
  Fall 2010 New Shows Average
Metascore
  Change
CBS   5: positivepositivepositivemixedmixed 58   5: positivepositivepositivepositivenegative 58   --
Fox   5: positivepositivepositivenegativenegative 55   3: positivepositivemixed 65   ↓10
NBC   6: positivepositivemixedmixedmixedmixed * 55   7: positivepositivepositivemixedmixedmixednegative 52   ↑3
ABC   7: positivepositivepositivepositivenegativenegativenegative 53   5: positivepositivepositivemixedmixed 58   ↓5
CW   4: mixedmixedmixednegative 47   2: positivemixed 59   ↓12
    All Fall 2011 New Shows: 54   All Fall 2010 New Shows: 57    

* Does not include the news program Rock Center with Brian Williams.

After two straight years with the highest average Metascore for its new fall series, Fox tumbled to second place in 2011 (thanks in part to the late-arriving critical disaster I Hate My Teenage Daughter), surrendering first place to CBS. Interestingly, Fox and CBS are also the two networks that have enjoyed a successful fall in terms of ratings; both networks have grown their audience since 2010. Despite a slight uptick in quality this fall versus last year, NBC's ratings have continued to plummet, while ABC—the network with both the most positively reviewed new shows as well as the most negatively reviewed ones—has also suffered, though not as severely.

The fall season's best and worst new shows

As we indicated above, only one broadcast network series managed to crack fall's top five: the ABC sitcom Suburgatory, which placed fifth. Metacritic users, however, seemed to respond better to the broadcast offerings, giving three network shows high marks. And, as always, the broadcast networks were able to secure all of the spots on our list of worst-reviewed shows. So there's that.

Best Reviews from Critics - Fall 2011 (New Series Only)
#1 #2 #3 #4 #5
Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar
91 78 75 75 70
Homeland
Showtime
Boss
Starz
Whitechapel
BBC America
Enlightened
HBO
Suburgatory
ABC
Best Reviews from Metacritic Users - Fall 2011 (New Series Only)
#1 #2 #3 #4 #5
Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar
8.2 8.0 7.8 7.7 7.6
Revenge
ABC
Homeland
Showtime
American Horror Story
FX
Once Upon a Time
ABC
Person of Interest
CBS
Worst Reviews from Critics - Fall 2011 (New Series Only)
#1 #2 #3 #4 #5
Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar
30 31 33 34 36
Charlie's Angels
ABC
H8R
The CW
Last Man Standing
ABC
I Hate My Teenage Daughter
Fox
Man Up!
ABC
Worst Reviews from Metacritic Users - Fall 2011 (New Series Only)
#1 #2 #3 #4 #5
Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar Image bar
1.6 2.5 2.7 3.3 4.0
H8R
The CW
Allen Gregory
Fox
Charlie's Angels
ABC
How to Be a Gentleman
CBS
Whitney
NBC

New television series with 7 or more reviews and debuting on U.S. television between August 15, 2011 and November 30, 2011 were eligible for the above lists. Shows are scored and ranked based on reviews published at the time of the original first season debut; returning series are excluded from these lists. The Metascore is a weighted average of scores from top professional critics, on a scale from 0 (bad) to 100 (good). Although scores have been rounded to the nearest whole number, shows are ranked prior to rounding. User scores represent an average of scores assigned by Metacritic.com site visitors on a scale from 0 (bad) to 10 (good). All scores as of December 1, 2011.

All new fall shows

Finally, here are the scores for all of the season's new shows with at least seven reviews from professional television critics, ranked from best- to worst-reviewed.

Metascore Ranking of New Primetime Series - 2011 Fall Season
  Show (Network) Genre Metascore Users
1Homeland (Showtime) Drama918.0
2Boss (Starz)Drama787.3
3Whitechapel (BBC America)Drama75n/a
4Enlightened (HBO) Comedy/drama756.2
5The X Factor (Fox) Reality competition705.6
6Suburgatory (ABC) Comedy707.3
7All-American Muslim (TLC) Reality697.4
8Pan Am (ABC) Drama677.2
92 Broke Girls (CBS) Comedy666.4
10New Girl (Fox)Comedy667.1
11Revenge (ABC) Drama668.2
12Once Upon a Time (ABC) Drama/fantasy667.7
13 Prime Suspect (NBC) Drama667.4
14Person of Interest (CBS)Drama657.6
15Up All Night (NBC) Comedy646.4
16Terra Nova (Fox) Sci-fi/drama645.9
17Hell on Wheels (AMC) Western637.5
18A Gifted Man (CBS) Drama627.1
19American Horror Story (FX) Horror617.8
20Ringer (The CW) Drama596.0
21Good Vibes (MTV) Animation/comedy58n/a
22Unforgettable (CBS) Drama575.3
23The Secret Circle (The CW) Drama557.3
24Grimm (NBC) Drama/fantasy557.1
25 Free Agents (NBC) * Comedy515.2
26Whitney (NBC)Comedy504.0
27 The Exes (TV Land)Comedy49n/a
28 The Playboy Club (NBC) * Drama455.9
29Hart of Dixie (The CW)Drama436.8
30 How to Be a Gentleman (CBS) * Comedy423.3
31Allen Gregory (Fox)Animation/comedy392.5
32Man Up! (ABC) Comedy365.9
33I Hate My Teenage Daughter (Fox)Comedy34n/a
34Last Man Standing (ABC)Comedy334.6
35 H8R (The CW) * Reality311.6
36 Charlie's Angels (ABC) * Drama302.7

Shows are ranked by Metascore prior to rounding. Minimum 7 critic reviews needed for inclusion.
* Show has been canceled.

What are your favorites?

What are your favorite and least favorite new shows of the fall season? What did the critics get right and wrong when first assessing these new programs? Let us know in the comments section below.

Comments (1)

  • LynchOrwell  

    Love Homeland with a passion. Damian Lewis is brilliant. The dud of the year to me would have to be American Horror Story. It's horrible cliched and leaves you not caring what happens.

New in Metacritic Reports

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/70th-primetime-emmys-winners-list-reviews Image
    2018 Emmy Awards: Full Winners List + Critic Reviews
    September 17, 2018 - 1 comment
    1. CollinP : Season 7 of Game of Thrones paled in comparison to the previous six, what a disappointment to see it take the trophy.... Read »
  2. /feature/picks-for-who-will-win-2018-emmy-awards Image
    2018 Emmy Award Predictions from Experts & Users
    September 14, 2018 - 2 comments
    1. mrstoked : Not one nomination for the best show of the year, The Terror? What were the Emmy nominators watching? Excellent... Read »
    2. LamontRaymond : Emmy voters just didn't get Twin Peaks Season 3. It's a monumental achievement - not surprised they couldn't figure... Read »
  3. /feature/metacritic-must-play-games Image
    New on Metacritic: Must-Play Games
    September 12, 2018 - 1 comment
    1. LamontRaymond : I like how you've always had a special view of 90+ games, like your "Best Games of the Year" articles, etc. - I... Read »
  4. /feature/september-2018-movie-preview Image
    11 Films to See in September
    August 30, 2018 - 2 comments
    1. eli_fjr : Predator! Read »
  5. /feature/metacritic-must-see-movies Image
    New on Metacritic: Must-See Movies
    June 11, 2018 - 3 comments
    1. NotAHero : It would be really cool if we can have special pages with list of these must-see movies by every year or some other... Read »
  6. /feature/major-upcoming-video-game-release-dates-xbox-ps4-pc-switch Image
    Notable Video Game Releases: New and Upcoming
    September 17, 2018 - 11 comments
    1. eli_fjr : Red Dead Redemption!! Read »
  7. /feature/25-best-ios-games Image
    Quarterly Report: The 25 Best iPhone/iPad Games
    June 30, 2018 - 13 comments
    1. ZiggySir : I think there are a few good games missing, home we have been lately playing (non-stop) Fold the Flock (Virtual... Read »
  8. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    2018 Fall TV Premiere Calendar
    August 14, 2018 - 179 comments
    1. JP25 : You posted the show "Save Me" would debut on Starz on Thur. 9/6. You should have noted it would be on the Starz app.... Read »
  9. /feature/elementary-cbs-season-1-critic-reassessment Image
    Fall TV Second Look: Elementary (CBS)
    October 26, 2012 - 3 comments
    1. happywheelssaz : Thanks for your article! I have read through some similar topics! However, your post has given me a very special... Read »